Medical services that only offer online booking options are leaving older people to 'give up' and wait for a call, an inquiry into specialist fees has heard.
Public specialist waitlists are “appalling” but there is no plan and no accountability from governments to meet the soaring demand, the Tasmanian branch of the AMA has told an inquiry into specialist fees.
Looking at specialist fees as the main problem ignores the bigger picture of rising practice costs, stagnant Medicare rebates and training bottlenecks, the AMA Tasmania representatives told the hearing in Hobart today.
The Inquiry into access to and affordability of medical specialists in Australia also heard warnings that medical services “cannot go digital only”, with the experts warning that older people were “giving up” when faced with online-only booking options.
Anaesthetist and AMA Tasmania immediate past-president Dr Michael Lumsden-Steel said waitlists in the state were “appalling” but said there was no clinical service plan or strategic discussion on how to meet demand for services in the state.
“Where is the accountability for the public healthcare system to be meeting the demand? Private healthcare should not be a necessity. It should be by choice.
“Why are we forcing people that are low socio-economic or pensioners that are struggling to maintain their private health insurance, to have to go and see a private specialist because the public system isn’t being staffed to meet demand?
“It is absolutely appalling, and there is no accountability at this stage for why the state’s not doing it.”
Dr Lumsden-Steel said a critical issue in Tasmania was that services were capped by the lack of investment in electronic medical records.
“We do not have a functioning electronic medical record in Tasmania, so we don’t have Epic. We don’t have any of these big ones.
“Everything is still pretty much paper-based.”
Dr Lumsden-Steel also took aim at the influence of religious organisations on patient access to medical care, referring to Calvary Health Care’s acquisition of Healthscope’s Hobart Private Hospital.
“This is raising several challenges to access specialist care,” he said.
“Regardless of what anyone thinks, the public hospital cannot click its fingers and pick up the work that was being done in private because it’s already over capacity.
“If you’re a patient on the IVF pathway, the Catholic Church doesn’t want to know about it.”
Dr Lumsden-Steel said patients who requested voluntary assisted dying were being moved from Catholic hospitals to public hospitals.
“We had a clinician tell us that at the last minute there was a big push to get a patient transferred to the public hospital because the Catholic hospital wouldn’t support it.
“Now, for goodness’ sake, a patient is dying … and this is how we’re treating our patients on that pathway. It’s appalling.
“Unfortunately, we’ve got this interplay of religion and politics. It’s actually now directly impacting patients, but also specialists.
“These private specialists run small businesses. They can’t be stuffed around trying to come at the public system when the public system finally gives them a green light to do a private patient because the flexibility is gone.
“If you’re having a termination or you’ve had a miscarriage, you need specialist management.”
Dr Lumsden-Steel said some medical services had become more expensive, but indexation had not reflected that.
“We need to get honest about what the cost providing a service really is.
“There’s no actual ownership of that from the government. We’ve got a medical cost finder site that’s being set up to make sure there’s transparency around fees.
“But every time we’ve asked the government, can you be transparent around how you’re determining …. a fee? Crickets.
“Until we see actual honesty about acknowledging the cost of services, then at the moment all we’re doing is flogging doctors and saying you guys are greedy and charging a fee that’s not appropriate, when there’s no acknowledgement that the rebate’s not meeting the cost of services.”
GP and AMA Tasmania president Dr Meg Creely urged the committee not to make the assumption that out-of-pocket costs were the result of specialist fees, saying that specialist consultation rates have grown more slowly than wages.
“Patients are becoming more complex, but also the options to treat them are becoming more complex,” she said.
“Defining specialist fees using whichever measure is inherently difficult and really detracts from the idea that it’s the Medicare rebate that is creating the gaps that are there.
“There is a perception that the fee that goes to the doctor to see them is that doctor’s fee, and it goes into their pocket.
“We have to pay the rent. We have to pay the medical indemnity. We have to pay for CPD … we have to pay nurses’ fees.
“All those other costs have also risen at the same time that … the patient’s Medicare rebate has not.”
Looking at specialist fees as one part of the problem “ignores that bigger picture”, Dr Creely said.
“Public outpatients plays a big role. The number of consultants we have to provide the care, both in private and public, plays a big role in that.
“Alongside just measures of cost, it’s that bigger picture around where does private specialist care exist within the continuum of the complexity that is our healthcare system.
“I work as a GP, and it is a really difficult position at the moment to be in to refer somebody to a non-GP specialist, have them sit and wait, whether that’s public or private, and to watch their health deteriorate during that time.”
Dr Creely said one of the main problems was the training pipeline “bottleneck”.
“We’re training a lot of medical students, we’re training a lot of junior doctors, but we bottleneck at that point where they become accredited registrars on a training program, and we bottleneck again when they come into that point of a consultant position in a public hospital.
“One of the members I was talking to today was saying essentially you have to wait till somebody dies to get a consultant position.
Dr Creely said workforce modelling had to match the demand of the population of Tasmania, which was older with more chronic and complex disease.
The longest outpatient waitlist in Tasmania was 5.7 years for non-urgent paediatric immunology, she said.
“Some of those children will not be children by the time they reach the end of that waitlist.
“We know allergy is on the rise, but we’re not trained. We haven’t gone back to the beginning and looked at how do we train to meet that need, both in public and in private?”
Dr Creely said the Medicare schedule fee should not be used as a base to calculate an acceptable price, “because for so long it hasn’t kept up with the actual cost of doing care”.
“I don’t think the Medicare schedule fee should ever be used by whatever multiples of it is to define what we think an acceptable price should be, because for so long it hasn’t kept up with the actual cost of doing care.”
‘We cannot go digital only’
Earlier today, Health Consumers Tasmania acting CEO Hannah Fielder told the hearing there was a divide between those who could afford to pay for specialist private specialist care and those who could not, with the latter group staying on those wait lists “for as long as they need to be there”.
“Tasmania is the most regionally dispersed population in Australia, and … we really see that trend between people outside of major centres having increased issues with accessing any care, but especially specialist care.”
Ms Fielder said people were often forced to travel interstate for care and were fearful of losing access to specialists if they were unhappy with their care.
“When people have a real fear of not being able to access any other specialists … they may not raise issues that they’re having with their specialist … whether that’s around billing practices or around quality of care.”
COTA Tasmania CEO Brigid Wilkinson said every day, COTA heard from older people who gave up trying to book an appointment because the only way to do it was through a QR code, with the belief that they will be contacted when they’re at the top of the list.
“They just give up because there’s that added issue around that digital exclusion because that’s the way a lot of these services are going.”
When asked about service providers who want to move to a “digital first” model, Ms Wilkinson said:
“We cannot go digital only. It’s not even an age thing. It’s an access and inclusion thing.
“A huge amount of people that we go out and see don’t have an email address, might have a mobile phone, but have no idea how to use it to book an appointment.
“What we’re seeing more and more is medical and other services not giving any other option but an online option, and that’s meaning people give up.”
Ms Wilkinson said access to specialist care should be determined by clinical need, but older people could be waiting for years.
“For an older person … a referral that might be marked non-urgent for a specialist can still mean months and sometimes years of pain, declining mobility, or increased reliance on family,” she said.
“Accessing the appropriate specialist support for chronic conditions is really crucial for older Australians, and delayed access to specialist assessment can therefore undermine the ability to remain independent,
“Those consequences should be recognised in measuring access and patient outcomes, rather than just treating the absence of an acute emergency stay as the sole predictor of whether the system’s working.”
